It really only works in orgs that are large enough to accept a bit of bloat, mature enough to have good managerial practices and invest in growing managers, and where the new manager has only a couple reports (2 is the perfect number). So you take a very good, senior IC who wants to be a manager, you cut their IC duties by 25-50% and you give them 2, maybe 3 direct reports. This is after doing some sort of formal managerial training, internal or external, and with the acknowledgement from their director/senior manager that they're going to be spending more time with them for the next 2-6 months and having skip 1:1s to make sure everything is going ok.
How many organizations do you think check all those boxes and are willing to do that? It's not many.