If the Rust language specification is precise enough to avoid disagreements about intended behavior, then multiple compilers can be written against that spec and they can all be expected to correctly compile Rust source code to equivalent output. Even if no international standards body has signed off on it.
On the other hand, if the spec is incomplete or underspecified, then even an ANSI/ISO/IETF stamp of approval won't help bring different implementations into alignment. C/C++ has been an ISO standard for >30 years and it's still difficult to write non-trivial codebases that can compile without modification on MSVC, GCC, Clang, and ICC because the specified (= portable) part of the language is too small to use exclusively.
Or hell, look at JSON, it's tiny and been standardized by the IETF but good luck getting consistent parsing of numeric values.
I’m all for multiple backends but there should be only 1 frontend. That’s why I hope gccrs remains forever a research project - it’s useful to help the Rust language people find holes in the spec but if it ever escapes the lab expect Rust to pick up C++ disease. Rust with a gcc backend is fine for when you want gcc platform support - a duplicate frontend with its own quirks serves no purpose.
I also hope Rust never moves to an ISO standard for similar reasons. As someone who has participated in an ISO committee (not language) it was a complete and utter shitshow and a giant waste of time taking forever to get simple things done.
> I’m all for multiple backends but there should be only 1 frontend. That’s
> why I hope gccrs remains forever a research project - it’s useful to help
> the Rust language people find holes in the spec but if it ever escapes the
> lab expect Rust to pick up C++ disease.
An important difference between Rust and C++ is that Rust maintains a distinction between stable and unstable features, with unstable features requiring a special toolchain and compiler pragma to use. The gccrs developers have said on record that they want to avoid creating a GNU dialect of Rust, so presumably their plan is to either have no gccrs-specific features at all, or to put such features behind an unstable #![feature] pragma. > Rust with a gcc backend is fine for when you want gcc platform support
> - a duplicate frontend with its own quirks serves no purpose.
A GCC-based Rust frontend would reduce the friction needed to adopt Rust in existing large projects. The Linux kernel is a great example, many of the Linux kernel devs don't want a hard dependency on LLVM, so they're not willing to accept Rust into their part of the tree until GCC can compile it.> A GCC-based Rust frontend would reduce the friction needed to adopt Rust in existing large projects. The Linux kernel is a great example, many of the Linux kernel devs don't want a hard dependency on LLVM, so they're not willing to accept Rust into their part of the tree until GCC can compile it.
How is that use case not addressed by rust_codegen_gcc? That seems like a much more useful effort for the broader community to focus on that delivers the benefits of gcc without bifurcating the frontend.