Some will be easier than others, sure. I'm trying to decide how "safe" my data is, since I created a single-use gmail account, with fictitious name, and paid for it with a gift card. I was afraid that some information in there might lead to being uninsurable, so I decided to row away from the rocks. Thankfully, my genetics didn't pop up any red flags, knock on wood.
I guess if you signed up using your normal e-mail address and your real name and used your credit card, you can still take the Shaggy defense ("It wasn't me"), but I suppose at that point they could ask you to prove it. I mean, most businesses aren't obligated to do business with you, for any or no reason at all.