Hacker News Reader

Comment by paddim8 | Hacker News Reader

The only difference is that you have to specify the type of the list when you declare it though... That's not really a big deal.

List<string> names = ["Peter", "Julia", "Xi"]; names.Select(name => $"Hello, {name}").ForEach(greeting => Console.WriteLine($"{greeting}! Enjoy your C#"))

new List<string> { "Peter", "Julia", "Xi" }.Select(name => $"Hello, {name}").ForEach(greeting => Console.WriteLine($"{greeting}! Enjoy your C#"))

View on HN

Nothing is that much a big deal on a small selected sample, on the one hand on the other. That is, maybe some will prefer mandatory explicit type for every single variable, and some other will prefer type inference whenever possible, and both have pros and cons.

To jump in a REPL (or any debug breakpoint observation facility), having optional type inference is a great plus to my mind.

Note that Crystal does allow to make type explicit, and keep the fluent interface on track doing so:

    Array(String).new.push("Peter", "Julia", "Xi").map{|name| "Hello, #{name}"}.each{|greeting| puts "#{greeting}! Enjoy your Crystal"}

Let’s remark by the way that, like with C# lambda parameters, block parameters are not explicitly typed in that case.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com