Hacker News Reader

Comment by jessekv | Hacker News Reader

What are bricks good at? Are they purely aesthetic?

Structurally speaking, concrete and wood clearly have their place, bricks just seem like a worse concrete to me.

In the absence of other influences, people tend to build with whatever is both cheaper [to buy and to use] and most-available.

If clay bricks are plentiful and cheaper in an area, then clay bricks tend to be used.

If dimensional lumber is plentiful and cheaper, then dimensional lumber tends to be used.

Same with concrete, or steel, or whatever. It varies regionally because the availability and cost of resources also vary regionally.

Not purely aesthetic, but they tend to be used for façade (brick veneer) rather than structural purposes these days. I can’t imagine you’d find much new construction that has solid masonry walls anymore.

Well, poured concrete is a relatively new technique. Most of the industrial areas in New England were built before that. All the those factory were built when brick was the material to build with.

They're a lot less ugly than concrete and they don't burn.

Heat retention. You know, kind of important in the winter.

Brick (r value ~0.80) reflects about as much heat as plywood (r value ~0.68). Alone, they are both terrible insulators, which is why we use air gap and better materials like fiber or vermiculite to fill the walls.

Where structural bricks are used, they are generally hollow with air cavities of varying sizes. Those types of bricks are very good insulators, pretty much the best insulation we had before modern fibres. Even if we used solid brick, their thermal mass alone would help regulate interior temperatures.

Hmm. That's not been my experience, both as a factory worker and former materials salesman (most of which were foams used as insulation). In the factories, the walls are typically concrete block with hollows (sometimes called cinder block) and I can tell you first-hand that in our Winters, when the temp hits below 32F consistently, those walls are very, very cold, as is the inside of the shop despite the efforts of our +250kBtuH heaters and keeping the bay doors closed as is common practice in the Winter months.

In my travels to other factories in the Southern parts of the US, we encounter the opposite problem. Brick shops are almost always too hot despite reasonable ventilation and climate control measures. There is definitely something to be said about where the structure in is the world when it comes to choosing appropriate building materials.

Sawing wood by hand is terribly exhausting work.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com