Hacker News Reader

Comment by Kapura | Hacker News Reader

weird metaphor, because a gym goer practices what they are doing by putting in the reps in order to increase personal capacity. it's more like you're laughing at people at the gym, saying "don't you know we have forklifts already lifting much more?"

View on HN

That’s a completely different argument, however, and a good one to have.

I can buy “if you use the forklift you’ll eventually lose the ability to lift weight by yourself”, but the author is going for “the forklift is actually not able to lift anything” which can trivially be proven wrong.

More like, "We had a nice forklift, but the boss got rid of it replaced it with a pack of rabid sled dogs which work sometimes? And sometimes they can also sniff out expiration dates on the food (although the boxes were already labeled?). And, I'm pretty sure one of them, George, understands me when I talk to him because the other day I asked him if he wanted a hotdog and he barked (of course, I was holding a hotdog at the time). But, anyway, we're using the dogs, so they must work? And I used to have to drive the forklift, but the dogs just do stuff without me needing to drive that old forklift"

I see it as almost the opposite. It’s like the pulley has been invented but some people refuse to acknowledge its usefulness and make claims that you’re weaker if you use it. But you can grow quite strong working a pulley all day.

"If you want to be good at lifting, just buy an exoskeleton like me and all my bros have. Never mind that your muscles will atrophy and you'll often get somersaulted down a flight of stairs while the exoskeleton makers all keep trying, and failing, to contain the exoskeleton propensity for tossing people down flights of stairs."

Reply on news.ycombinator.com