Any individual station that gets out of sync either works hard to catch up, or gets disconnected.
The problem, as I see it, is that the load signal is equal and equivalent to the sync signal and maybe they could be separated. (e.g. the FM modulated signal wouldn't have to be a sine wave, nor would it even have to be 50Hz)
> what if two or more power stations see a low frequency grid and decide to ramp up more generators?
Seems to me it would solve this problem - they both have a single invariant sync signal.
> Connect a stopped, or sufficiently out of phase generator to a full scale power grid and the puny thousands of pounds of metal that make up a generator are going to get ripped apart
Seems to me this problem is solvable with electronics, but I don't know enough to say how much out-of-phase is problematic. What if, as you say, some heavy load is switched on, the local nuclear turbines slow by a fraction for a few 10s of seconds, and so a home PV array starts leading by 0.01Hz (e.g. home PV at 50.00Hz, local power station at 49.99Hz, so after 10s the PV is fully 36º or 0.6rad ahead). Does this result in the inverter (or the small local windfarm) exploding? Is that a realistic scenario?
> there needs to be more communication across the grid than just responding to the locally observed frequency
Precisely - a grid-wide sync signal, modulated at high frequency.