One benefit of doing it on the client is the client can cache the result of an include. So for example, instead of having to download the content of a header and footer for every page, it is just downloaded once and re-usef for future pages
In server terms the overhead of tracking one download is going to be less that the overhead of tracking the download of the multiple components
And for client side caching to be any use then a visitor would need to view more than one page and the harsh reality is many sessions are only one page long e.g. news sites, blogs etc