You are completely correct. You should always look at the performance. In fact, you should be focused on your own performance.

I was merely displaying the parts of that performance and illustrating that one part of it is far more volatile and the other is less so. Knowing that fact alone, if you had invested in divindend paying securities and focused on the cash flow of the economy, you would have been personally better off.

Not all stocks pay dividends. Not paying attention to that can bring you closer to the -1.5%/an and farther from 4.9%.

>>Not a good return, but you also picked one of the worst dates.

I have picked the current situation. We can talk about historical rosy times in the market, but that is somewhat beside the point. This is our current reality.