Why? If they're taking a fixed-route shuttle, why is their only alternative a different sub-service of Uber?
Why? If they're taking a fixed-route shuttle, why is their only alternative a different sub-service of Uber?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_high_...
Literally what is the difference between a fixed route shuttle operated by Uber versus a bus operated by the city, except that one siphons the profit into a private company? I imagine flexibility of imagination more than practicality.
If Uber can do it, especially if they can do it profitably, I'm at a loss as to why a city government could not accomplish the same. This seems like a vastly better approach, cities have to start somewhere. -- https://www.sixthtone.com/news/1017072 | https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43980845
One, the technology already works. If I visit Dallas or Philadelphia, I already have the app. Getting set up (and familiarised) with each city's app as a visitor is a friction.
Two, smell. This is absolutely classist. But Uber will probably do a better job keeping someone who hasn't bathed in two weeks out of their system than the public bus system. We could wish upon a star and poof away class structure in America. Or we could admit that running Uber shuttles between busses increases the system's throughput with minimal downside.
Three, flexibility. These shuttles will automate before any union-controlled public bus system in America has a chance to.
City governments generally have stricter requirements for whom they have to service. Private companies can fire their pathological customers more easily.
No, our cities are extraordinarily poorly designed.
They're built in such a way that the only way to get around in a cost-effective and time-effective way is by taking a private vehicle.
Here in Dallas, TX, we have the DART and it's pretty expansive. But the city is huge and sprawling - Dallas is still basically a suburb pretending to be a city. A typical 20 minute drive is going to be an hour on the DART. There just isn't enough density to make train and bus stops make sense in almost all US cities.
No? I agree with you about the layout favoring personal vehicles of course.
Maybe their goal IS to run city busses out of business. Maybe they're about to FAFO.
Hell, the municipality can wait to see if it works, and if it does, launch a public competitor.
Also low density makes public transit less accessible, requires mode shifts, and, of course, the time cost of public transit vs cars.
Unfortunately that means low income folks who can't afford 5-10x higher daily fare (and I think that's a decent guess) are excluded from living there. But sure, if we assume a public transit system should be profitable (and I personally disagree with that) you'd end up unable to service expensive to reach areas.
I concede that's a rock and hard place situation though.
What I can see as an upside is that if Uber's brand lets them short circuit the classism and normalize not using a car all the time. That's also a prerequisite for a healthy bus system, generally you have to build the transit and make it reliable before expecting people to stop driving cars, people have to be able to reliably get around. So if it makes people feel secure in not owning one, when public bus routes are added they'll actually have riders and not get discontinued after a month trial.