That's not just near a the line. That's not just over the line. That's "absolute fucking evil" territory.
Somehow it always ends up as projection, and none of those same people will care about literal death panels.
Sometimes people are unable to vouch for themselves, or demand very invasive procedures. It's easy to claim that others deserve to have their demands met about procedures in the face of rational argument.
My parents have a DNR because they are both doctors and have spent too much time forcibly keeping people alive-ish because they were ordered to keep people on the edge of death alive, consuming incredible amounts of money, manpower, probable pain, and medication to keep someone barely alive for a week or two.
So many people are kept alive in arguably incredibly painful and shitty situations because of the inability to deal with the fact that sometimes people die
I entirely agree with your parents about the level of effort, not to mention the unpleasantness, pain and suffering associated with fighting off a natural death.
But in the context of this article, we are specifically talking about the patients themselves, having coherently expressed a wish to be resuscitated were being pressured into signing DNR paperwork.
That's not the same thing as your situation, and I say that as someone who has had to coach hundreds of family members through end of life events, both expected and unexpected. I have done things like ordering continuing CPR on a patient who had no survival outcome expected, just because he was still minimally responsive and his spouse was almost there to say goodbye (he was bleeding internally and could not be stabilized for surgery). She got to squeeze his hand, and feel him squeeze hers back before we discontinued resuscitation and allowed him to pass. And I have done things like brought the "head of the family" into the resuscitation bay because he and the family were adamant in the face of all reality that "God was going to pull their father through" the cardiac arrest he was in. Though painful, it took him but a few minutes to grasp the reality, that all stops had been pulled out, but that we were at the end of the road. Following that, he was able to understand, ask us to discontinue, and be able to go back to the family and explain.
But marking somebody as having a DNR when they do not want one is evil.
Everyone can easily make a choice willingly to not file a DNR if they do not know what that requires. So now your grandmother is getting is a intubation tube shoved down their throat, chest compressions, and whatever and is not a state to figure out "wow this fucking sucks" anymore, also someone just collapsed your rib-cage giving you chest compressions.
Keep you alive at all costs is easy to agree to if you have no fucking clue what "all costs" mans
Your implicit argument is that if the patient doesn't sign a DNR, and their family/HCP doesn't sign a DNR, that it is ethical for the medical system to do it anyway on their behalf. If you want to make that argument explicitly, go right ahead. But it's going to get rejected out of hand in a thread about the healthcare industry making such decisions out of expedience, and rightfully so.
That's exactly the behavior you're defending.
You don't just pick up a POLST form at the grocery store. You have to get one from your doctor and go through it together. https://doh.wa.gov/public-health-provider-resources/emergenc... is the one in my state and it is very clear about exactly the things you mention. Full treatment is described as:
"Primary goal is prolonging life by ALL medically effective means. Use of intubation, advanced airway interventions, mechanical ventilation, and cardioversion as indicated. Includes care described below. Transfer to hospital if indicated. Includes intensive care."
The care described below includes "IV medication access", "invasive airway management". It even includes "assisted nutrition", i.e. feeding tubes or ports.
It also requires a demonstration of comprehension of these choices by the patient, not just the HCP.
> someone just collapsed your rib-cage giving you chest compressions.
Frankly, while not pleasant, most people who walk out of a hospital post-arrest have recovered from this in days, and it is generally not particularly painful (because contrary to popular belief, you almost certainly haven't broken ribs, just separated some of the sternal cartilage around the xiphoid process - the little notch midline at your lowest non-floating ribs). There are far more important concerns.
I was a paramedic (and before, an EMT) who has responded literally thousands of times to SNFs (skilled nursing facilities).
Dozens, if not hundreds of these calls were for the most trivial of concerns. A nurse told us at one facility that their policy was "anything larger than a bandaid, call 911", so we'd do "first aid" while two nurses stood by and watched us. I'm sure they (the facility) had motivations on liability, etc., but nonetheless, it was utterly galling that you'd leave such a facility and see big proud billboards or ads offering "24/7 nursing care!" - and knowing that they were certainly charging the patient or their family for a rate commensurate with that, potentially five digits a month, while offloading all their work to 911 and relying on skeleton crews of an LPN per floor supervising way too many CNAs.
They'd also routinely "forget" to fill out paperwork on ambulance necessity (Medicare, and many insurers, have paperwork to justify why the patient was not suitable for private vehicle or wheelchair van transport and instead needed a "fully equipped BLS/ALS ambulance"). It wasn't onerous, a single pager with a bunch of checkboxes, "Does the patient pose a fall risk?" "Need for oxygen?" "Unable to support themselves in a sitting position", etc. But we'd have to fight tooth and nail to get anything more than "patient name, DOB, and an illegible provider signature". Insurance would routinely reject payment, etc.
UHG involved in more of these shenanigans? Not surprised. They were slapped several years ago for denying HEMS (Heli EMS, aka "Life Flight") from severe MVA / trauma scenes due to lack of pre-authorization... ("This is John, I'm a paramedic working on one of your patients who was hit by a truck. We would like to fly him to the hospital due to his extensive multisystem trauma but we need your authorization. His name? Hang on, let me find his wallet. No, that's Smythe, S-M-Y-T-H-E, sorry, I know, it's a bit loud with the jaws of life in the background... Uhh, sure, I guess I can hold for a nurse consultation...")
At this point, it looks like criminal murder charges (seeking the death penalty) + federalizing the company would be minimal next steps towards fixing the problem.
Of course, that won't happen under the current administration.