That's all well and fine, no one is forcing you to build or use software this way. But there are domains where this is the predominant UX design and it's proven to be robust for decades.
Reading between the lines a bit and from browsing some mailing list posts/gh issues, it seems like Wayland developers have a deeply held arrogance towards application developers that are surprised to find out the applications they have been developing for years are "wrong." The truth is that GUI software on Linux is already a minefield (which is why most people don't bother to support it) and making it less-like-Windows is not going to make it easier for people to port their desktop applications. I get the desire for targeting things-not-like-Windows (tiling WMs, VR, tablet/mobiles, etc)... but those aren't desktop applications.
It seems crazy to me that there's so much feedback from desktop application developers that is being ignored or dismissed.