People for the most part are very friendly and welcoming (yes, including of people who aren’t like them).
WI is traditionally a working-class blue state — not incredibly progressive, but probably better than average (it did, unfortunately, go for Trump both times though).
Madison is a lovely (and very liberal) city with good cycling infrastructure. Maybe people aren’t flocking to Milwaukee, but it’s a nice enough city.
I grew up in the country, at the end of a quarter mile gravel road, and have had mostly front-wheel drive cars. 4WD is not a prerequisite to living in Wisconsin.
We got fiber in our rural neighborhood in 2009. I’m not a football fan (I do, however, own a few guns). Yes, the bugs suck.
I’m sorry for your experience.