Central planning is a risky move - you’re essentially putting all your eggs in one basket. When it works well, we all benefit. When it works badly, we all suffer for it.
End of the day, design can be from architects imposing their views or tax collectors and road engineers doing theirs. The worst design comes from the genius planners, the best usually from people working with well defined constraints of money, taxes and build expense.
The state of American architecture and life is almost completely based on tax policy and allocation of resources to roadways. Our cities of vacant office towers are almost completely a tax story.
Also a financial leverage story. Rendering the true market value of these towers would create balance sheet issues at quite a few institutions. No one is keen to rock that boat.
Without the tax incentives people would still have left the biggest cities.
My parents bought their first home in NYC for $19,000 in 1977. They sold it in 1993 for $500,000, and that owner sold it in 2024 for $2.8M. Nobody paid capital gains.
Thanks for calling out commercial. That's something I'll have to study more.
Absolutely not the case. American suburbs are the result of massive planning restriction and financial subsidy.