> Miranda rights apply to criminal arrests but immigration arrests are typically civil.

> The 6th Amendment guarantees the right to a lawyer

I think people arrested by ICE are not guaranteed a lawyer, because, as you say, it's a civil matter. This means if you find yourself sleeping on a cot behind a chain link fence in Alligator Alcatraz, and you want to speak to a lawyer, you'll have to pay for it yourself, because it's all a civil matter.

Are we great again?

If the end result is that people are forcibly abducted, extradited, and thrown into an El Salvadoran prison without due process, I really don't give a shit what the law says. It can't be described as "civil."

Due process is ultimately what keeps this from happening to YOU.

Something being into law doesn't change reality. It is abduction even if the Pope and the Queen sign on it, period. Remember not everyone in the planet is American, this is like quoting North Korean law to justify some random atrocity.

It is Hacker News so of course someone is gonna rationalize fucking abducting people.

What type of "immigration arrests" are valid against citizens?