your clarification on mechanics doesn't address my core concern: this policy forces people who bought affordable homes decades ago to either pay significantly more or sell when their neighborhoods gentrify. who benefits when they're forced to sell? developers who can afford both the LVT and development costs.
so we're transferring wealth from middle-class homeowners to wealthy developers and calling it progressive policy.
frame this as preventing "uncapped gains from appreciation," but these are people who just needed housing, not speculators. meanwhile, actual investors get to buy the forced sales.
you still haven't addressed how LVT solves the actual constraint. in my market, a major developer cancelled a project because of constructions cost. not land value. if land availability isn't the bottleneck, how does your policy help? construction costs are the real issue in most markets.
this remains a policy that sounds elegant in theory but would be politically impossible and harmful in practice.