A lot of arguments are based on the supposed 'strange' orbit and not so much on any physical evidence. Feels very speculative to me.
"Unlikely. 3I/ATLAS's hyperbolic orbit (e=6.2) and high excess velocity (~60 km/s) strongly indicate an extrasolar origin, as solar system perturbations (e.g., by passing stars) rarely produce such inbound speeds for bound objects like those in the Oort cloud. The puzzling 0.2% [probability of] plane alignment suggests other anomalies, warranting further study."