He's not saying it's only true when salaries are equal. It makes a significant difference at the margin: if you're an employer debating whether to employ US talent or offshore talent, weighing time zones, skill and other factors against cost, then introducing a tax advantage for domestic hiring will cause those employers who were otherwise indifferent between the two options to now prefer US labor.
Only if the tax advantage more than offsets the difference in cost.
5 vs 15 year - debatable.
Immediate vs 15 yr? - no where is that cheap.
If the foreign team is only half as expensive, that still leaves you with $300k instead of $0 in the example given.