You’d need some scheme for synchronization if you want to reduce power consumption.
The tradeoff is:
- The end nodes can spend the vast majority of the time in deep sleep without the radios turned on.
- The base station has access to a bigger power source (usually line voltage) and doesn't care about turning its receiver off.
- You can't, however, send data to the end nodes at arbitrary points in time. You have to wait for them to send to you and you have to reply back to them before they go back to sleep.
In a peer-to-peer system like the one in the article you don't get to make this tradeoff.
1. Each node transmits a beacon once per second.
2. While they aren't connected, each node listens for sub subset of time (say 10%).
3. Eventually one node will hear the beacon from the other. They can use this to synchronize clocks (the better your clocks the better this works).
4. Thereafter they just wake up periodically at the same time and one transmits a beacon to the other to synchronize (alternating whose turn it is).
It's the same idea as sleepy edge devices used in IoT, but just both ways. Quite a lot more complicated of course, but you can totally do it.
With the walkie-textie type system you're making a different tradeoff here though that would have to be measured and assessed. Now you've got a couple of knobs to twiddle with:
- What's the max acceptable latency between sending a message and receiving it? That determines your beacon interval and becomes the factor that determines your battery life (effectively your Rx duty cycle + Tx beacon energy).
- Does transmitting the beacon at your beacon interval and only having the receiver run in a limited window around that beacon result in a larger or smaller net power consumption? That's going to depend significantly on your transmit power vs. receiver power.
On 868Mhz you get 36 seconds per hour or even 3.6 seconds per hour.
Depending on your power usage sending may also be very slow.
Then again, the primary user of 434MHz is actually amateur radio, on which you can operate beacon transmissions if you care to!!
Low-power requires you to turn the receiver off for extended periods of time, but what you can do there is limited by how interactive the device needs to be, and how much the power the transmitter is willing to waste on retries/longer preambles.
For proper low-power (e.g., devices with ≥ 1 year battery life on small batteries), you're likely to need sleep periods of minutes to hours, or only waking up on physical interaction.