Hacker News Reader

Comment by richardfeynman | Hacker News Reader

Additionally, when Israel gave Gaza to the Gazans in 2005, it wasn't fenced in yet the Gazans still attacked Israel, demonstrating the attacks weren't being about fenced in, but rather a visceral hate towards the yahood. The fences were built after the second intifada.

View on HN

> when Israel gave Gaza to the Gazans

You’re so deep in propaganda you don’t even see how this sentence demonstrates the entire issue huh?

This is an accusation without meaning. You don't know what information I see, so you don't know whether I see propaganda at all. The reverse is true as well; I don't know what information (or propaganda) you see. But no, I don't see how Israel giving Gaza to the Gazans (something Egypt never did) demonstrates "the entire issue," whatever you happen to mean by that.

You are commenting on a propaganda article.

You have posted the same authors links before.

You consume hacker news at all.

Your implicit assertion that you consume no propaganda itself belies your naïveté to politics as a subject.

You are not commenting in good faith. The author, a respected computer scientist with deep knowledge of this issue, is not a propagandist; you just don't like what he says. I have been on Hacker News for well over a decade, I'm not some fresh two year old account like yours. And I didn't say I don't consume any propaganda (I'm sure I do), it's you who said I'm "deep into propaganda" which is a false and evidence-free statement.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com