I don't like Chat Control and I believe privacy should be guaranteed, but Europol seems quite relevant in this matter.
I don't like Chat Control and I believe privacy should be guaranteed, but Europol seems quite relevant in this matter.
Police is supposedly for protecting people's interests, ideally.
Naively, as a citizen I want to be protected from crime and I'm interested in Europol, experts on crime investigation across Europe, getting what they need to do their work and expressing their needs.
Of course I'm also not interested in privacy being thrown away.
Those two things apparently clash, and a healthy debate can help find an acceptable solution.
> Police is supposedly for protecting people's interests, ideally.
Police is supposedly for enforcing the law regardless of whose interests that serve. Making that enforcement easier isn't always a net positive for society, even when the laws themselves are just.
Unfortunately we don't live in an ideal world and I agree with you that in practice, law enforcement isn't always a net positive.
It's its role, theoretically (I don't know about transparent, but protecting citizens for sure).
Of course, the reality is not ideal.
Police may prefer to suppress freedom to achieve its goal, which is crime reduction. Or it may stop caring about difficult or dangerous problems (say, drug dealing cartels), and reorient into harassing the civilian population for petty things, such as policing distasteful memes on the internet.
We are not talking about power or decision making, we are talking about expression.
I'm really confused as to how some people here misunderstand this discussion as being about giving law-making power to the police.
I'm of course against a police state.
edit: I'm not even defending Europol or what they actually do, there are things they do I most certainly don't like.
Unfortunately, I don't have much of this. I wish I could!
Happy you wrote this so I could clarify this point.
This is rule of law 101, and has been figured out hundreds of years ago. Without separation of powers, you cannot have rule of law.
I think any organism should be able to express their needs and voice their concern.
That's of course not the same thing as deciding.