Please no. Remember that room temperature superconductor nonsense that went on for way too long? Let's please collectively try to avoid that..
The only advantage to closed peer review is it saves slight scientific embarrassment. However, this is a natural part of taking risks ofc and risky science is great.
P.s. in this case I really don't like the paper or methods. However, open peer review is good for science.
Actually, from my recollection, it was debunked pretty quickly by people who read the paper because the paper was hot garbage. I saw someone point out that its graph of resistivity showed higher resistance than copper wire. It was no better than any of the other claimed room-temperature semiconductor papers that came out that year; it merely managed to catch virality on social media and therefore drove people to attempt to reproduce it.