Hacker News Reader

Comment by Mr_Eri_Atlov | Hacker News Reader

[flagged]

Indiscriminately is a loaded term. There is always some reasonable suspicion. Usually law enforcement always knows which pockets of a city, neighborhood have more illegal activity and can act based on that prior information.

It is well documented they have detained people who are here legally.

Citizens who showed them a photo "Real ID"!

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/may/24/us-citizen-d...

He was interfering with the arrest, recording video etc. At least he didn’t get assassinated for exercising his first amendment rights like Charlie.

Your comment doesn't preclude the comment you're replying to being true.

Quit it with the fear mongering

If this white Canadian woman traveling to California can be jailed for two weeks, then it can absolutely happen to anyone: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/19/canadian-det...

As a Canadian, I'm refusing to travel to the US right now, despite working remotely for a US-based company.

It's not fear mongering, it's real. But my motivation isn't even just fear; staying home or choosing to travel elsewhere (Europe, Asia, Mexico) is standing with my countrymen against a regime that doesn't respect our sovereignty or even its own laws.

That sounds like US immigration has always been, during the GW Bush and Obama and Biden administrations.

It can be argued that a lot of this is falling into the slippery slope fallacy.

Also the media doesn’t always report the full story. Often the people arrested have some small/medium offense from years ago.

Unlikely to happen to legal immigrants.

Nonetheless, I will continue to choose to spend my travel dollars elsewhere until the US administration is crystal clear that Canada is a sovereign country, due process is a thing, and vanning people off of street corners (regardless of their skin colour or immigration status) is not the way.

Many of them have a small offense that would justify them being turned away from the border, but not an offense that justifies detention.

That’s fair. And if they can be turned away from the border, then they can be deported too.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com