You could create an iTunes playlist with your songs.
1) Create a playlist with all the songs.
2) Right click on it, and click "duplicate".
3) Drag the songs to the order you want. Remove any songs you don't want in this set.
4) From the menu, go "File -> Print" and select song list.
Repeat steps 2 to 3 as many times you want. You can also rename the set playlist, to reflect the set name (e.g "2012-22-09").
Alternatively: you could also use some "todo management" style software to print lists of things (in your case, song names) that you can re-arrange.
Bento might also be an option.