What? Yes it is! This is exactly how peer review works! People look at the paper, read it, and then reproduce it, poke holes, etc.
Peer review has nothing to do with "being published in some fancy-looking formatted PDF in some journal after passing an arbitrary committee" or whatever, it's literally review by your peers.
Now, do I have problems with this specific paper and how it's written in a semi-magical way that surely requires the reader suspend disbelief? For sure, but that's completely independent of the "peer-review" aspect of it.