"Chuck nobody knows what they are going to be when the chips are down, they can think they will be a tiger but they sometimes they discover they are the deer, and stare transfixed at the headlights. The best you can do is test people early to get a sense of how they respond and move the ones who can't act in a crisis into safer jobs."
I have found this to be very accurate advice. People who you wouldn't think would freeze up can (and do) and people who you felt were meek and softspoken can suddenly stand up and take charge. Its the fight-or-flight instinct and its wired in the part of the brain you don't have a lot of control over. It sounds like your CEO friend discovered he couldn't take the pressure and ran. It can be a shameful place for a proud person, it has driven people to suicide. Understanding that its not under your conscious control can help.