There is no relationship between history (which is subjectively narrated), logic (which is an abstraction) and politics (what are arbitrary).

If you had an understanding of what history is, you'd understand it has no scientific validity.

https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262537995/how-history-gets-thin...

As there is no scientific basis for history, and there is no logic to politics (it is irrational), nothing stated by Alexander is valid.