If you discourage public participation in prediction markets "oh I will just lose my money to an insider a few hours or days before the final result, so why bother", then the end result is that nobody participates until an insider makes a big bet. Then the market is worthless until the insiders jump in. Is that really what prediction market advocates want?
The other point is that:
> Prediction markets don't provide capital for productive businesses
Is not true. There's more than just capital in terms of cash. There's human capital (employees), brand value... and importantly, information. Which is what prediction markets intend to do in the future: become an information value source for productive businesses.
Money isn't the only unit of value.
Allowing insider trading seems like a nearsighted way to increase volume for prediction markets, at the cost of long term value.