One important goal of Unicode is to be able to convert from existing character sets to Unicode (and back) without having to know the language of the text that is being converted. If they had invented a separate code point for I in Turkish, then when converting text from those existing ISO character encodings, you’d have to know whether the text is Turkish or English or something else, to know which Unicode code point to map the source “I” into. That’s exactly what Unicode was designed to avoid.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO/IEC_8859-7