As for the 'carriers in space' thing that he thinks is incorrect, it's at odds with the rest of what he says. While he does defend his point with a function of sea carriers providing the interface between sea and air, that's not all they do. The aircraft carrier doesn't function as a battleship, the fighter aircraft do. The carrier functions as a support ship, an auxilliary, to the craft doing the fighting. Same in space. The large support carrier gets to hold the supplies, living quarters, extra fuel and so on, and the small craft contain the bare necessities for waging battle without having to lug around needless support slowing them down (remember also he talks of issues regarding mass and agility). I'm not saying that it's viable, just that there's more to a carrier than 'sea/air interface'.