Subtract billionaire activity from your perception of EA attitude: is this critique still true? Who specifically makes it so?
But that's the problem, that is my entire perception of EA. I see regular altruism where, like in the shopping example I gave above, wanting to be effective is already intrinsic. Doing things like giving people information that some forms of giving are better than others is just great. No issues there at all, but again I see that as a part of plain old regular altruism.
Then there is Effective Altruism (tm) which is the billionaire version that I see as performative and corrupt. Even when it helps people, this seems to be incidental rather that the main goal which appears to be marketing the EA premise for self promotion and back patting.
And no, it’s not really. This negative branding mostly exists among people who actually will admit to knowing it’s not even accurate to them.
"A lot of people think that EA is some hifalutin, condescending endeavor and billionaire utilitarians hijack its ideology to justify extreme greed (and sometimes fraud!), but in reality, EA is simply the imperative (accessible to anyone) to direct their altruistic efforts toward what will actually do the most good for the causes they care about. This is in contrast to the most people's default mode of relying on marketing, locality, vibes, or personal emotional satisfaction to guide their generosity."
See? Fair and accurate, and without propagating things I know or suspect to be untrue!
Why so?
“Well Kathy Griffin and Carrot Top fit the bill”
Do you think that is a fair characterization of red headed people in general?
“Not really, but I’m allowed to say so anyway.”
…
Sure I guess?
They'll insist on propagating it anyway, but they will actually say they don't actually believe it themselves!