Moreover, what's the theory on which it could work? If you have the capital to buy a building solely to collect rents on Airbnb, what stops you from just unloading the building if/when your reputation becomes a meaningful obstacle, and then just using a different shell to buy and let out a different building?
I think there's a lot of thinks Airbnb could do here; I like Airbnb. But I'm always a little skeptical of the magical powers of "reputation systems".
The 'buy a whole building just to rent it out' case is a little more ethically dubious for me, but normally that kind of operation isn't too hard to spot from afar, and I can't imagine AirBnB guests being too thrilled staying there.
As a fellow tenant, my level of comfort with my daughter running unattended to a friend's apartment in the same building is less if I know there are lots of people running AirBnB sublets out of their apartments than if I know everyone is a resident subject to a background check and on a 6-12 month lease.
Maybe the increase in risk from transient AirBnB tenants is small, but it's not zero. That loss of comfort, and that non-zero increase in risk is a harm to the other tenants in the building.
EDIT: I was actually talking about the subletter (person who signed the original lease) rather than the landlord of the property itself.
I think people who are proponents of AirBnB dramatically underestimate how much monetary value people attach to the kind of people they live around, especially in city apartment buildings where lots of people who barely know each other live in close proximity. A condo in a building that has some fraction of renters can sell for substantially less than an identical condo in an identical building that is 100% owner-occupied. Rents at buildings with 12-month minimum leases are higher than rents in buildings with 1-month minimum leases. People go out of their way to buy into coop buildings that have minimum down payment requirements, etc.
I live in an apartment in downtown Chicago. The major businesses in the area are Northwestern Memorial Hospital and Northwestern University. Thus, most of the residents are medical residents, nurses, graduate students, etc. This tenant composition is priced into my rent. We have a lot of families that live here because it's a bit away from all the tourists on Michigan Ave and because every tenant undergoes a background check. If a bunch of tenants started illegally subletting their apartments on AirBnB to aforementioned tourists, that would upend everyone's expectations and decrease the value of the building to all of us.
Who do you think poses a bigger risk to other tenants, my cousin's friend who's crashing with me in Chicago while he finds a place to stay permanently, or someone with 100 positive reviews on AirBnB? 20 positive reviews on AirBnB? Where do we draw the line on what's ethical here? I think most people wouldn't see any problem with the first scenario but would with the second, but the risk is probably lower in the second scenario.
(Perhaps AirBnB should purchase insurance on behalf of AirBnB landlords. I'm sure they have data on how often these kinds of problems occur and I can't imagine it being too expensive)
EDIT: Looks like they already do have insurance of some kind: https://www.airbnb.com/guarantee
Also, the building management company would evict tenants who had troublesome guests, which provides the tenant (AirBnB host) with an incentive to only take people who are reliable.
So you're left dealing with an unfortunate subset of landlords.
I agree, but I have a feeling that it won't play out that way in practice.
I would have agreed with you up until about 2 years ago. I've been a home owner for a good 10 years now, we moved a couple of years ago into a new neighbor hood.
Most of hte homes are very nice and well kept up, but the ones that are the most in need of repair are the rentals. And subsequently the houses beside them take a hit in property value.
We know most of the renters and they are nice hard working people who do the upkeep( cut grass, weed flower beds, etc), but the large repair items are always left undone.
the painting, shingling, gutter cleaning, etc. And it makes sense for both parties not to do it. The renters don't care and the home owners don't care about their property values until they sell.
Sadly though having renters in a neighborhood brings down property values. I'm pretty certain that having a high concentration of AirBnB renters would bring down values even more.
So there is harm done, a fair bit of it.
Now obviously this is an extreme example, but stories like this aren't totally unheard of. If you know several people who rent out properties regularly, chances are that they have a couple of horror stories between them.
If you own a house in the middle of the woods, you bear all the risk for the quality of your renter. If you live in a condo building, the other tenants are exposed to that risk. In the former case, I can totally control the level of risk I'm exposed to based on my choices of who I host. In the latter case, if I'm a fellow tenant, I have no control over that risk. The AirBnB host in my building might only choose tenants with 100+ reviews, or they may choose tenants with no reviews.
I would suggest trying AirBnB a little and looking at what the people who actually use the service are like first without worrying about some kind of imagined stranger danger.
My point is that as a tenant in a building with an AirBnB host, I have absolutely zero guarantees about what kind of tenants AirBnB hosts take on. Maybe some need the money and are willing to take on people with no reputation scores? I'm willing to trust my building management to take responsibility for screening tenants because if they fail I can sue them and I know they can pay because they are insured.
That's the point you keep dancing around. AirBnB's reputation system might be great. That's irrelevant to me as a tenant in the same building. I don't get to see or have any control over the reputations scores of the people AirBnB hosts in my building take on. The AirBnB host exposes me to a level of risk, he is in total control over that level of risk, and he doesn't carry insurance against that risk. That is a harm to me.
Not really, my point was with respect to who cares for their property the most: owners > long term renters > short term( 1 week or less) renters
However, at the moment, the landlord's not doing anything illegal at all. How can we deal with this kind of scenario effectively?