Who do you think poses a bigger risk to other tenants, my cousin's friend who's crashing with me in Chicago while he finds a place to stay permanently, or someone with 100 positive reviews on AirBnB? 20 positive reviews on AirBnB? Where do we draw the line on what's ethical here? I think most people wouldn't see any problem with the first scenario but would with the second, but the risk is probably lower in the second scenario.
(Perhaps AirBnB should purchase insurance on behalf of AirBnB landlords. I'm sure they have data on how often these kinds of problems occur and I can't imagine it being too expensive)
EDIT: Looks like they already do have insurance of some kind: https://www.airbnb.com/guarantee