The Chesterton’s Fence argument is an argument against progressive social changes, no?
It’s perfectly fine to be for progressive social changes, as long as those criteria are met.
I’d call that a pragmatic approach, not a conservative one.
The other meaning of "conservative", the one that's opposite "reckless".
It should in theory be possible to take a conservative approach to being progressive.
That's likely how most of the middle see themselves (if not in those words) - open to new changes but only if they're fully understood and not drastic.