2000: good ME: bad XP2: good Vista: bad 7: good 8: bad
2000: good ME: bad XP2: good Vista: bad 7: good 8: bad
I would argue no to all those notions. I think Microsoft in 2012 is a much more disciplined, focussed, and frankly ambitious company than it was in 2002 or 2006. The development of 7 and especially how the company communicated with the public about 7 was a quantum leap from Vista. As far as I can tell, Microsoft has carried forward all of those improvements into the process of building 8. If it is making mistakes with Windows 8, they are entirely different genres of mistakes than it made with Vista or ME.
Even Apple is subject to these media cycles (see antennagate, batteries exploding etc), they just manage to deflect them to smaller items, stuff most people don't care about. Microsoft seems to struggle much more when trying to control product perception across media channels.
NT4 (Good) 2000 (Not) XP (Good) Vista (Not) 7 (Good) 8 (Not)
98 - good, ME - fail, XP - good, Vista - fail, 7 - good, etc. (Although this whole idea is pretty silly to start with ;-))