When the political environment becomes unstable, people need to reach out to communities that they trust. For some people, here is where they are comfortable, and where they meet people whose character is legible enough to them that they can place trust. By saying "no politics here" you're denying the people who find this their safe space the ability to share their fears about the situation.
IMO the main difference between the current US administration and those usually considered authoritarian, is that it does not yet use violence to discipline it's own side. But if it remains, that is an unavoidable step on the roadmap. It's supporters are acting like democracy and the rule of law can be denied to some people, while they retain them; that is not a sustainable state of affairs. "Business as usual" is short-sighted.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
"Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."
I also think it's a dumb rule.
It is supremely naive to think you can excise political discussion, and if you're wondering why people are so upset at techies these days, this is a hint at the reason. Techies are people who think they can just say "no politics" and they did something good or got rid of politics.
Your opinion.
> endless low-effort, kneejerk commentary by people spouting their side's talking points.
Straw man. And also a low-effort, kneejerk comment spouting your side's talking point. I see a lot of irony there.
A matter of opinion.
It’s also the law of this place, and that is not a matter of opinion.
Guideline. Guidelines are not laws. Want to know what else is an HN guideline? "Please don't complain that a submission is inappropriate" right along with "Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit".
And even if it were true that it's a law, it would still be entirely irrelevant to the discussion of whether it's dumb or not.
> and that is not a matter of opinion
"unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon" is a matter of opinion. Evidence of, interesting, new, all matters of opinion.
These aren’t opt-in issues.
I get that you are upset but they should certainly be opt-in issues, here.
If people from Kyiv, Gaza, Sudan, Syria, Congo, Venezuela or Rwanda can come here and contribute to topics of tech and curiosity without making it about their situation, then so can anyone else.
There is value in having sanctuaries. Their existence doesn't mean you have given up.
Even if that were accepted as fact (it isn't), tech complicity in fascism and genocide shouldn't ever be among such issues.
> There is value in having sanctuaries.
There is, and there are many. But this isn't your sanctuary.
Never was, and never should be.
> If people from Kyiv, Gaza, Sudan, Syria, Congo, Venezuela or Rwanda can come here and contribute to topics of tech and curiosity without making it about their situation, then so can anyone else.
Imagine seeing 9 of your 10 children get blown up with the aid of Microsoft and Google and Amazon tech, then reading the above sentence on HN.
Really. Imagine it.
Imagine it. Imagine how you would feel. Imagine the rage. Feel it.
As I understand it, this place is about technology and curiosity, not fascism and genocide,
There are plenty of other places talking about fascism and genocide, this is not one of those places.
>There is, and there are many. But this isn't your sanctuary.
Since the story has been flagged I still feel it's my sanctuary. And I think it's right to flag it.
>Imagine seeing 9 of your 10 children get blown up with the aid of Microsoft and Google.
I would feel no rage, as I don't believe anyone, ever in the history of Google or Microsoft, intended to blow up any children, anywhere. Not once.
I want to discuss dotnet, dart, gmail, visual studio, android, and whatever else from those companies, without having to deal with what horrible people do with their technology.
I want to emphasize that the topics you mention are important too, just not here.
You have apparently not yet connected the dynamics driving so much enthusiasm for fascism and genocide. The tech industry owns this problem.
Most of these threads are flagged anyway, so if you want to be a part of this discussion you have to check /active. This seems like an eminently reasonable compromise, with only the occasionally discussion being rescued from the flagging gauntlet and bubbling up to the main page.
> only vaguely HN related
This story is entirely under HN's remit. HN’s purpose is explicit. It is not “keep things comfortable.” It is “curious, informed discussion of what matters in and around tech.”
When a top tech firm is materially enabling coercion or violence, and even dodging the press over it, that is a tech story first and foremost. And it matters.
Besides which: Your argument is very old, and has been rejected many, many, many times.
> there are so many communities that have fallen, and I don't want to lose another
What killed r/technology wasn't 'politics'. It was mass censorship, shit mods, brigading, clickbait farming, and allowing the toxic elements to spread bs unchecked. You know, like when you let any users flag stories and then unaccountable mods with no logs very selectively unflag the ones they like.
Censoring 'political' topics just makes the smartest and coolest people leave. And our tech companies have been complicit collaborators in far too many serious crimes lately to trust things to work themselves out without even looking at them.
Tech companies have been deeply entangled with states and coercive institutions for decades, now up to the point of genocide, concentration camps, and masked thugs with "total federal immunity". Pretending that’s off-limits isn't community preservation. It's wilful ignorance and must be firmly rejected.