If this happened in real life, the actual fear would be getting car jacked by her and the five guys at her "home." Not a false rape accusation that will be ignored by the police.
I had a very attractive young woman ask me for a ride once, I turned her down for safety reasons, I didn't even have to imagine what bad things might happen, this is just common sense.
Someone asking for a ride is "so contrived"? You don't have to believe them but dude what are you even talking about.