That would be a good reason.
If so then I am sure that they thought through the liability issues (if any). I'm curious if there are any interesting ones.
The only thing that comes to mind would be a case where the ownership of a piece of IP is disputed. ContentID lead to Youtube recognizing that it was copyrighted, and paying money to the person that they thought was the copyright holder. The copyright holder now sues Youtube for infringing on copyright, and Youtube has deep pockets and no safe harbor.
I am not sure how realistic this case would be.