I understand what he's saying, but a legal defense based on the response to an HTTP GET constituting de facto permission to access whatever that URL addresses is going to be disappointed. I'm not saying the defendant here is guilty; I'm just saying, he's not not guilty simply by reason of HTTP.
As a matter of law, the onus is not on the operators of web applications to ensure that their defenses are effective. If you do something stupid in your web app, but it remains clear to me that I'm not meant to access whatever your stupid app failed to prevent me from accessing, I can still be charged with a felony for doing it.
Now, if whatever it was that you tried and failed to protect wasn't obviously protected, so that I can argue in court that a reasonable person would have believed they did have permission to interact with it, I'll probably win in court. The prosecution will no doubt collect all my emails and any other piece of evidence it can find to build a case that I knew I wasn't supposed to hit your site that way. If you were especially dumb, and built an application that not only exposed sensitive information, but did so in a way that any normal person would just have assumed that sensitive information was theirs for the taking, the prosecution will have a hard time making their case.