Maybe here lies the crux; for some of us, the web and by extension the internet is about expression and individuality in a way, but all together all accessible by everyone. Everything looking the same instead looks conformist, and ultimately boring, which I guess is what many of us don't want day after day. We want new ideas, presented by the person/group who came up with it, in the way they would express it. The LLM kind of trashes the parts that add up to something interesting.
It's not just about being the same, in which case the worst is that it has less to stand out with.
It's about looking the same as the other AI generated slops out there, which is a strong signal that the content is probably AI slop too, which doesn't merit time being spent on it and trying to understand if it's slop or a human that just used AI generated UI.