Profitability was an index rule removing it adds garbage to the portfolio
No longer. But it has an extremely valuable brand - did you know S&P has hundreds of indexes? Do any others readily come to mind?
It was originally supposed to be “close enough” to the entire market. We don’t need to do that anymore. But they want to, to milk that valuable brand. Profitability is an arbitrary rule for an antiquated index. Let it die.