I am very much not a pro-social media person (this is a social media website, btw) but I am even less a nanny state person. EU loses plenty of support from the citizens of its constituent states when it implements these sorts of limitations, so I hope the benefits meaningfully improve quality of life.
Also, research is not a prescriptive cure, and it isn’t a neutral domain. It is valuable, but not as an unevaluated rubber stamp.
Restricting access to the latter does not impact privacy.
And which implementation of age verification would not cut off from the "restricted" side (including the "adult" part, i.e. exactly the part for the kids) of the Web the Normal People? Those that say "if my privacy is suspected to be impacted I will adoperate to cease life on Earth". I am not aware of a practical system that warranties privacy while performing age verification.
And: the implementation, "doing it right", should be the chief point of debate. Not the vile "for the kids", that already denounces that the proponents are scum. (Everyone is capable of pointing to a problem: adequate good /solutions/ are all that can exist for administrations.)
> deeply harmful to society
So are knives, and both forbidding cutlery to minors and impeding adult access to cutlery are signs that some societies are finished and requiring cessation.
And the perpetrators of such damage should pay.
Absolutely not: it's objective. You "are doing it wrong". You must have a very naïve idea of that part of the Web. Read below.
> YouTube ... an essential, and irreplaceable part of the internet
Oh yes it is. It's the video half of it. And it means that "half" of the paramount intellectual contributions are there.
The "news" are there (the Springfield times and the Patagonian Mirror), the "intelligence" (the interview to the Prestigious, the interview from the Authority, the exchange from the Thinkers, the commentary from the Author, the piece from the Periodical...), the "institutes" (the Conference, the Presentation etc.), the "academy" ("""only""" the courses of the MIT, for example, and courses from many other Universities and free Professors), the "divulgation" (a large amount of divulgators of primary importance from 3blue1brown to Steve Mould, Lesics, Asianometry...), the inquirers and commentators in all areas and disciplines, the museum of the historical pieces that must be preserved out of preciousness and importance (from the voice of Freud to the lessons of Dirac), and a massive wealth of Arts and good entertainment.
The value of the above is beyond the scale; its attendance should be taken for a requirement.
A kid that grows up without access to that is something that must be disposed of, wasted, spoiled - "sorry kid, in the ditch. You have not been exposed to Culture, now you are valueless. These things must be absorbed early".
And beasts that restrict access to e.g. the _free_ lessons from the MIT are to be treated as less than beasts.
The problem is doing it in a way that doesn’t removal all privacy.