The details matter (training set, full context). I doubt our current LLMs knows what smelling cut grass on a wet morning feels like, or how the stomach flutters on a first kiss - even if they have "read" tens to hundreds of attempts at describing such things.
You're essentially suggesting we play Turing's Guessing Game; if your LLM can guess my response to any prompt - then it can be said to have modeled how I would reply to those prompts. Expand the prompts far enough, and you could reasonably argue the LLM models me.