First, the truth status of this sweeping statement is hard to assess, but I think it's more wrong than right. If you had to complete your sentence "The most important...", I think you'd better put installation, or perhaps conceptual art, rather than photography.
It would be better not to make such statements at all -- doing so combines two notoriously slippery concepts, "art" and "most important". (If we can't define art, and good luck doing it, then defining most important art is well out of reach.)
Anyway, you and the comment above you are talking across each other. You're saying that photography is important to contemporary art. jberryman is saying that the most common use cases of photography are not art, and tend to be documentary, not aesthetic. Both of you can be right.
It would be better not to make such statements at all...
-- As you said.
http://artblart.files.wordpress.com/2012/10/hyman-writing.jp...
_____________________
[1] Citations for context, if you need them.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_expensive_photogra...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhein_II
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Topographics
Non-topographic 19th Century art with 20th C influence:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Cameron_julia_jackson.jpg
_________
Is "Photography is at the cutting edge of contemporary art"?
http://www.amazon.com/Why-Photography-Matters-Never-Before/d...
_________
Does art exist?
http://books.google.com/books/about/The_Objective_Eye.html?i...
__________
I didn't say photography was unimportant. I said that it's hard to defend your statement that photography is the most important of the arts. I don't see you defending that statement.
I do see you putting words in my mouth, with quotes as if I wrote them ("at the cutting edge"). It's a tautology that photography is at the cutting edge of contemporary art. So is painting. So is multimedia installation.
Your last note ("does art exist") is puzzling, because nobody here said art did not exist. I did say it's hard to define, and lots of artists are working to keep it that way. Is a sculpture made of fingernail clippings art (http://strose.lunaimaging.com:8180/luna/servlet/detail/StRos...)?
This is an exhibition catalog excerpt. The artist (from the 1850's) is being exhibited because of his links to XYZ (the guy with the most expensive photograph ever sold at auction, linked above, in 2011). The Guy XYZ is a student of Becher (==New Topographics), the former a Pioneer of the original aesthetic now called Topographic/s. That, in a nutshell is the point I was making. Interesting stuff was happening in the 1800's. In Art. With Photography.
I didn't say photography was unimportant. I said that it's hard to defend your statement that photography is the most important of the arts. I don't see you defending that statement.
== I don't need to. Its not critical to the point.
If you have a true interest in the subject matter, its worth looking into further. I would encourage other HN readers to do the same, if they have an interest in it. The interesting stuff in contemporary photography is well-beyond what you've listed. I'd take that as an opportunity to learn more about the subject, rather than taking it personally. For the most part, it is German and Japanese leading the way. Books are your friend, and an increasingly good investment.
http://www.amazon.com/Photobook-History-2-Martin-Parr/dp/071...