I lost my old one, so ordered a replacement. Later I found the lost one, so I have two... The number is different, though, so I'm sure the old one is invalidated in the database. (Oregon)
If we lose ours, they reprint it with the same expiration date as the lost one, but the new one has "DUPLICATE 1" printed on it (presumably that 1 is a counter). But our drivers license number stays the same for life.