I made no claim that it worked well ;-). But it has been in place since the beginning of the Portland light rail effort in 1986 (now I feel old; I took a ride during the rollout celebration...). Much like other transit systems, fares are mostly for show (IMO, obviously) -- less than 10% of the operating expenses are covered by fares. I wonder, but do not have the data to make an argument, whether it would be basically a wash if we just abandoned fares altogether along with the cost of the equipment and enforcement personnel.
There was a time when the downtown area was fareless. The main argument in favor of ending it was that fares provided an enforcement mechanism for keeping undesirables (read: homeless) off the train. That is the main opposition argument, as well, from communities on the edge of the metro area who do not want any lines extended to them.