Any fact at all has significance. That there is some fact that can be derived using pure reason is quite astounding and it's the essence of Descartes' Cogito. By the way, there didn't "need" to be any particular fact at all that could be derived from pure reason (or any fact at all of course but that's trivial), this itself is a gift from G-d and very clever.
I doubt you really understand what I'm saying here, if you did you wouldn't have written the rest of what you did.
> Maybe there just is a neverending supply of predecessors
This is almost certainly the case. In terms of my personal aesthetic sense I find this to be good and pleasing because it matches various other phenomena, the fractal complexity of various phenomena in life (.e.g. designing a product, all the little details and the details of the details matter a great deal, this is why Apple is so successful compared to others). This type of endless complexity seems to be a divine quality (this is also why the Talmud is so long and it's commentaries and arguments about the commentaries and arguments on the minutia of various things). The moral structure of human affairs has this fractal complexity (in secular law this manifests as case law/common law).
> At some point the answer might be "literally nothing came before that" or "for no reason". We might find that unsatisfying but reality is not obliged to satisfy us.
There's no way to use science to prove "literally nothing came before that". You don't have a clear understanding of the structure of the scientific method or the "poverty of empiricism" (you should Google this phrase).
> (a') It could go on for ever without being infinite. Maybe everything is cyclic in some sense. Again, arguably unsatisfying but reality is not obliged to satisfy us.
"Everything" being cyclic is explicitly a teaching of Kabbalah (there is a basic 7000 year cycle mirroring the 7 days of the week, there is a broader 50,000 year cycle mirroring the 7 shmita cycles + 1 jovel/Jubilee). There are similar ideas about the cyclical nature of existence in the esoteric teachings of various other religions.
You're still talking about "everything" i.e. "something" i.e. existence. You still have to contend with "something from nothing", creatio ex nihilo. This is what Aristotle and others are talking about which you're fundamentally not understanding.
By the way, you see a scientific theory of this in Roger Penrose's "Conformal cyclic cosmology" which makes sense given that the inflationary universe theory is kind of illogical due to the inconsistent entropy regimes (this is something Penrose talks about frequently).
> You can call your "first cause" by any name you please, "God"
Yes exactly, you're close to getting it. We can call the "first cause" (or really, this idea/concept/understanding of the first cause) by any name we please, so for the sake of discussion let's call this first cause "G-d".
> but calling something a god doesn't make it one.
Yes this is exactly what I'm saying. You cannot go from this purely logical knowledge that there's G-d (or that there's "First Cause" or "Prime Mover" or "Uncaused Cause", whatever name you want to use) to the god of the Bible or whatever the term 'god' means to you personally. You cannot assign any particular nature or character or qualities using pure reason/logic.
Do you get it now? You're actually very close to getting it I think.
> The great majority of the masses in the "Western" world were (at least in name) Christian at the time of the Enlightenment and at every time since until very recently
What I'm saying is accurate and what was meant when Nietzche said "God is dead", yes "in name" but in practice the Enlightenment destroyed this. And yes it wasn't something that happened immediately as a result of the Enlightenment, that was an intellectual and aesthetic movement by elites, these things take time to diffuse to the masses (decades, centuries), especially in times before mass literacy and the Internet.