I'm sorry, could you possibly patronize me a little harder? Thanks.
Yes, any fact has significance. No, that doesn't mean that one can get from "you can keep asking why like a toddler" to any deep truths about the nature of reality. Descarte's cogito is a clever bit of sophistry but not actually a valid argument.
(In your other recent comment in this thread you inform me that I am not smarter than Aristotle and Descartes. Probably correct. The advantage I have over Aristotle and Descartes isn't a better brain but centuries of progress in understanding made by countless smart people; it doesn't even particularly matter whether any of them were smarter than Aristotle and/or Descartes.)
[EDITED to add:] Oops, I didn't read carefully enough; your earlier comment was addressed to someone else. I'm fairly sure you intended to include me among "the other reddit atheists", but it wasn't me you were informing and it's technically possible that I wasn't one of the people you were saying it about. Anyway, obviously it doesn't particularly matter; I just don't like leaving something inaccurate uncorrected in something I wrote.
> There is no way to use science to prove "literally nothing came before that".
Quite correct; there isn't. Which is one reason why I never said that there was. What I said was that "literally nothing came before that" might be the answer to one of those questions, by which I meant it might be the correct answer, not that science would be able to prove it.
(Science is never actually in the business of proving things. Every scientific discovery is in principle provisional.)
I think you might be able to save some of the effort you put into being condescending[1], if you refrained from giving everything I say the stupidest possible interpretation.
[1] Of course I'm joking; I am sure being condescending to me is a source of satisfaction to you and you'd rather do it than not. But I like to maintain at least the polite pretence that my interlocutor is arguing in good faith.
> "Everything" being cyclic is explicitly a teaching of Kabbalah
Sure. And of Nietzsche and of the ancient Mayans, if I recall correctly. (I might not; I am not an expert on either Nietzsche or the Mayans.) That has little bearing on how plausible it is that everything actually is cyclic, of course. Anyway, to whatever extent you find cyclic cosmologies more plausible on account of the idea being found in Kabbalah (or indeed in Penrose), you should be a little less impressed by first-cause arguments.
> You're still talking about "everything" i.e. "something" i.e. existence
I assume the point you're getting at here is that even if someone gives a complete account of the temporal and causal structure of everything in the universe it's still possible to say "OK, fine, and where did all that come from, then?". (And so ad infinitum.) It's rather galling to be accused of obtusely failing to recognize this when in fact I explicitly acknowledged it more than once in the comment you're replying to.
> for the sake of discussion let's call this first cause "G-d".
No, let's not. Because giving it that name smuggles in all sorts of completely unjustified implications. If any of these first-cause arguments worked (which, I repeat, they do not) there would be no justification at all for attaching any such label to the thing they purport to find.
Contrary to your earlier claim, no "first cause" argument shows that "God is". At most it shows that "some thing beyond which it isn't useful to keep asking why, is". And, as already observed, in fact it very much doesn't show even that, as evidenced by the fact that anyone can if they please keep asking "why" even if the last answer they were given is "God".