No, they shouldn't report on it. Did they ask OpenAI for proof? If so, that's not mentioned in the article. This isn't researched or vetted enough to report.
What proof would be acceptable? That could just as easily be made up.
"Proof" isn't the baseline for reporting on things.
Real journalism tries to verify sources. This doesn't even attempt to do that. There's no "the WP couldn't independently verify OpenAI's claim". It's just directly broadcasting what OpenAI says without even attempting to question it. This is not journalism.