Hacker News Reader

Comment by iso1631 | Hacker News Reader

The increased land value is because the land is more desirable. If I buy some land next to a rubbish dump, it's cheap because living there is terrible. If the dump is then closed my land improves in value, and I derive value from that.

Likewise if I buy somewhere cheap in a backwater town, and the town becomes more desirable because there are better employment opportunities, better shops, better amenities, all of which serve to mean people will pay more for the land, then I benefit from that immediately.

View on HN

The value is subjective, if you lived in a quaint town and now it’s become a bustling place it may be a nightmare for you , despite the price increases. That is actually a win win situation, though, since you can now move to another quaint town elsewhere while taking a pile of cash with you, with the perhaps important caveat that you do lose your proximity to places and people you may consider more important than the money.

These imaginary scenarios do not align with typical real world experiences. Very few people live near a dump that closes or see their small town unexpectedly boom (and as brabel notes, that’s not necessarily a benefit).

Most people’s home values go up because of 1) increasing housing demand and 2) the collective delusion that home prices can continue to far outpace wage growth indefinitely. Neither of these things necessarily result in an increase in amenities or improved quality of life.

My own home value has gone up something like 70% in the last 10 years. Meanwhile, the amenities near me are essentially unchanged. Same schools. Same number and quality of restaurants and grocery stores. My net worth has jumped a fair bit but my immediate benefit seems pretty much flat.

Increasing demand to live in the town.

Rents will have increased to reflect this increase in desirability, but you just expect to make a profit from it.

I do not benefit day to day from increased demand. That was the point.

The house is more desirable, evidenced from more people willing to spend more money in there. You benefit from the same things which make it desirable to other people.

And yet in 2 days of responding you’ve been unable to articulate how real homeowners benefit day to day from rising prices. My own home was in a highly desirable area long before I purchased it. I receive no clear benefits day to day from rising prices.

Merely insisting it’s true doesn’t make it so.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com